Kerala to review award after bishops protest Mulakkal cartoon

Published on June 12, 2019, Matters India Cleansing the Augean Stables of Sex abuse in the CHURCH is not only a herculean task, but an impossible thing to do, we wrote two weeks ago. Why? Because we are living in a Church of Constantine from AD 312. (Read; ccv, April 25/19: Cleaning up Church Augean Stables-Possible? )

Augean Stables

What does Augean stables mean? We wrote: “Augean Stables” harkens us back to the story in the Classical mythology, in which King Augeas kept 3000 oxen in stables which had not been cleaned for 30 years. It was finally accomplished by Hercules who diverted the river Alpheus through these stables to make them spick and span. Yes that is the Himalayan task Francis has taken upon his shoulders – cleaning up the Augean stables of  clerical sex abuse – ignored not just for 30 but 2000 years, ever since Constantine took charge of these stables – “to sweep clean the dust of the Empire accumulated on the throne of Peter since Constantine” to borrow the phrase used by Good Pope John XXlll.” 

Which means, it was Pope John xxiii who said, the Church we live in is that of Constantine from 313 and it was to sweep clean that “dust of the Empire” that the Pope convened Vatican II. This task still remains undone even after 50 years. What could not be done by the world’s entire bishops will not be done in the foreseeable future, unless and until, the pyramidal Church of the Empire of glory and honorific appellations, is destroyed lock-stock-and-barrel and dumped in the Arabian and other seas, is our conclusion. 

Become Cattle Class

The Church has to become the “people of God”, in our terminology, THE CATTLE CLASS of Jesus, born in Cattle shed, lived among the oppressed, suppressed and marginalized, without even a home address: “Foxes have their holes, birds of the air their nest, but the SON OF MAN….” and buried in a borrowed tomb. For that the Clergy-laity divide must go first; priesthood must be abolished and a whole set of “Indian Caste system” must be wiped out. Jesus never claimed to be a priest. How could he, the bitterest critic of the Priestly class, become a Priest, the biggest tragic comedy? He was and still remains THE EVERLASTING MAN of Chesterton, identifying himself with the whole of humanity. 

The philosophy of the Conquistadores: “Humanize, civilize and Christianize” was invented and promoted for the sake of the Empire builders, not by or for Jesus who never even called himself a Christian.  That name emerged first in Ephesus, years after Jesus’ crucifixion with the inscription INRI on the cross. He was born a Jew, lived a Jew and died a Jew, as the model SON OF MAN(94 times in the Gospels) for all humanity.  

Mulakkal Cartoon

Now the one who leads the Church in India, it seems, is Bp. Mulakkal – even cartoonists are after him — and all Indian bishops with varieties of “Augean stables” dance to his tune. We don’t, of course, ignore shining examples of self effacing bishops like Alex Dias of Port Blare now retired in Goa, Eugene Desouza of Bopal now in heaven and many others. 

You please read what people say (vox populi vox Dei) about the cartoon. To give a fitting background, we added below, a brief report, in Matters India, an article, how it all developed. Still the institutional Church in India stays unmoved sticking to defend its imagined “fair face’’ now tattered and disfigured. Only when the whole rot is exposed and washed clean, can the ‘Company of Jesus’ start germinating with a new philosophy. 

Competing to footwash

In that company the  propelling force is the competition to take the last place to serve, to do the foot-washing ministry, not the first place to rule or dominate, following the “self-emptying” model of Jesus, nor the second place sitting on the right and left of Jesus like James and John, as Prime Ministers in his kingdom. To reach that goal we may have to wait for an eternity!  

Hence our firm belief that cleansing the “Augean stables of sex abuse” is impossible to achieve in today’s Church of Consantine. So forget the Churches and Christianity, focus on Jesus and his humane humanity, reaching out to all, as brothers and sisters. “You are all brothers only,” has not Jesus said it?  james kottoor, editor CCV.

Please read below, report on

Award-winning Cartoon controversy 

The Kerala government plans to review an award-winning cartoon after it evoked widespread condemnation. According to Kerala Catholic Bishops’ Council (KCBC), the cartoon by Subhash KK shows the rape-accused Bishop in a bad light and hurts their religious sentiments.

The cartoon, which won Kerala Lalithakala Akademi award, depicts Franco as a cock, propped up by MLA PC George, who openly supported him, even as the nuns who spoke up are seen fleeing the scene. 

Although PC George is holding up Franco, the latter is seen standing on a police cap, suggesting that officials were lax in their duty. Also in the frame is P K Sasi of the CPI(M), who has been accused of sexual harassment. Both the bishop and PK Sasi are wearing the same headdress, making it clear that they are only versions of each other. 

There’s also a woman’s underwear drawn in the bishop’s staff that Franco carries. And right above the cartoon is written, ‘Vishwasam rakshati’, which sarcastically says “your faith will save you”. 

KCBC objected to the cartoon. A statement by KCBC spokesperson Father Varghese Vallikat called the cartoon incendiary and objectionable. “We suspect that the CPI(M)’s evaluation that Christians did not vote for them during the Lok Sabha elections was behind the decision to confer an award for this cartoon,” he said. 

KCBC was most offended by the underwear that the cartoonist had drawn on “the good shepherd” symbol. The statement said, “In the name of condemning Bishop Franco, the cartoonist has insulted Christianity by drawing an objectionable picture on the Good Shepherd symbol. The Left government in Kerala has honored such a distorted cartoon”.

While asking LalithaKala Akademi to apologize for the cartoon, KCBC also asked whether this was the Left government’s policy to help minorities and promote communal harmony. 

Following criticisms by KCBC, the Minister for Law, Culture and Cinema, A K Balan, said that the government will re-examine the award. In a statement, the Minister said, “While the government accepts the theme of the cartoon on Franco Mulakkal, we are viewing the insult to a religious symbol seriously. In the light of this serious issue, the government has asked the Lalit Kala Academy to review the awards given for cartoons this year.” 

Meanwhile, Subhash told reporters that he has nothing to say in this regard. “They (Lalithakala Akademi) have not contacted me or informed me about this decision. I don’t know anything about this matter and hence I do not want to react now. Let them inform me and once they do I will respond.”

Given below is the brief supporting history, also in mattersIndia;

Jalandhar rape case: Women theologians write to Pope

November 21, 2018 Matters India

By Matters India Reporter

New Delhi, November 20, 2018: The Indian Women Theologians Forum (IWTF) has written to Pope Francis expressing deep concerns over the way the Church in their country handles sexual abuse cases.

Around 800 Catholics from around the world have endorsed the letter sent to the Pope F with copies to ecclesiastical leaders in India, says a November 20 press release from the forum.

The letter highlights the context and facts regarding the case of sexual abuse involving the bishop of Jalandhar. It also comments on the lack of response and the inappropriate handling of the case by the Church authorities in India.

As remedial measures, the letter requests the setting up of an impartial enquiry committee with at least 50 percent women to study the allegations and taking adequate steps to support a fair trial in keeping with the Church policy of “zero tolerance of sexual abuse.”

It wants immediate implementation of the CBCI Guidelines, 2017 of the Church in India for addressing sexual abuse, in keeping with the civil laws applicable to grievance redressal mechanisms of the country.

The November 9 letter was endorsed by Catholics from 24 countries, with the United States topping the list, followed by Australia and Brazil.The Indian signatories came from 15 states, including nearly 500 from Kerala, where the complainant and the accused of the Jalandhar case belong.The signatories included 71 priests from India, more than 50 women religious and 16 advocates.

“In keeping with the need to be transparent in our efforts this letter is also mailed to 250 representatives of the Catholic Church, including all the cardinals and bishops within India,” the press release says.

The letter

Date: November 9, 2018

Indian Women Theologians Forum, IWTF India

His Holiness, Pope Francis

Apostolic Palace, 00120 Vatican City.
Dear Pope Francis,

Sub: A plea to intervene in the serious complaint of sexual abuse afflicting the Indian Church. 

The Church in India is reeling under the shock of a bishop being accused of sexually abusing a nun who was a former Superior General of the Missionaries of Jesus (MJ). The patron of this diocesan congregation is the Bishop of Jalandhar Diocese, in this case, Bp Franco Mulakkal, who is the accused person.

The alleged abuse occurred from 2014 to 2016, and from June 2017, for an entire year, the nun sought justice, appealing to the Indian bishops, the Apostolic Nuncio, members of the Curia and finally to you. Some local bishops she approached washed their hands off the case citing the fact that they belonged to the Syro-Malabar Church and did not have jurisdiction over a bishop from the Latin Rite. Finally in June 2018, in the context of threatening measures taken by Franco Mulakkal against the family members of the nun and her five supporters in the community and the persistent inaction on the part of Church authorities whom she approached, she filed a First Information Report (FIR) with the local police as a last resort to address the issue.

When the silence of the Church authorities persisted, some members of the Catholic Church, from across Kerala, organised a hunger strike outside the Kerala High Court on September 8, 2018. The MJ supporters of the complainant were requested to join the protest. A few priests and nuns from other congregations also joined in. Initially this was to be a symbolic one-day protest, but due to the growing clamour for justice for the afflicted nun, it was decided to continue the protest. Due to pressure of the public protests that went on for 14 days and the universal public attention it received in the media, the accused was finally arrested on September 21, 2018.

A Divided Church

The Church in India finds itself split between those who support the accused bishop and those who stand with the nun. Some hail the protesting nuns for taking a prophetic stand; others condemn them and see the complaint as frivolous, malicious and/or an attempt to besmirch the reputation of the Church in an already fragile political environment.

These divisions were heightened when the accused bishop received visits from his fellow bishops in prison, while the complainant, supposedly a daughter of the Church, was forsaken.

To make matters worse, on his return to Jalandhar after being granted bail, the accused was given a hero’s welcome, garlanded and showered with flower petals by his supporters in the church premises. The fact that the Apostolic Administrator did not intervene to stop this ostentatious welcome of the accused released on bail, communicates that the Church stands with the bishop in contrast to the neutral stand claimed officially by the Church.

We are deeply concerned by the lack of due attention and intervention by the Church authorities as well as the irreparable damage that has been done to the credibility of the Church in our multireligious society and the deep divide that has been created among the faithful. We find it reprehensible that the accused is still the Bishop of Jalandhar and resides in the Bishop’s house.

This is an open display of support for the accused by Church authorities, which delegitimizes the complainant and her complaint. We are dismayed by the initial silence of the bishops and their subsequent defence of this silence as these are signs of insensitivity to the pain and abandonment that the Sister survivor and her supporters are experiencing. Till date she has received no acknowledgement of her letters from the Nuncio, the Catholic Bishops Conference of India, or anyone from the Vatican.

The untimely death of Fr. Kuriakose Kattuthara on October 22, 2018, within a few days of Franco Mulakkal’s release is also very disturbing. He was residing in Jalandhar and had received reports regarding the alleged incidents of sexual abuse and the atmosphere of fear prevailing within the MJ community in Kerala. He was a prime witness against Mulakkal and a supporter of the Survivor nun. Fr. Kuriakose in recent public interviews went on record saying that he was being harassed, and feared for his life if Franco Mulakkal was released. There is evidence to show that Fr. Kuriakose’s residence had been vandalized at least twice after he gave evidence against Mulakkal in this case.

Address the Crime of Sexual Abuse

The complaint against Franco Mulakkal has brought to light several procedural flaws in the Church. There is a complete lack of clarity on what procedures and policies exist within the Church i.e. who can complain in these situations, to whom, how and what is the response and remedy available. There are no support systems for the complainant/survivor within the Church institutions. This is in spite of the fact that the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of India’s standing committee approved and passed the ‘CBCI Guidelines to Deal with Sexual Harassment in the Workplace’ in September 2017.

As remedy we seek:

•An official acknowledgment of this letter.

• The setting up of an impartial enquiry committee with at least 50 percent women, to report on how and why the systems in the Church failed to respond to this particular complaint, and implementation of the recommendations of this committee.

• The setting up of an impartial enquiry committee with at least 50 percent women to determine the facts of the allegations, and necessary action to be taken.

• Measures to ensure that the safety and security of the complainant and the witnesses are addressed as priority.

• That the accused no longer be allowed to reside in the bishop’s house as this is seen as a sign of the Church’s support, and further enables him to garner local support which may influence the case and be a threat to a fair trial.
• That the Holy See takes immediate action and remove Franco Mulakkal from the post of bishop of Jalandhar till the legal proceedings are completed.
• That the survivor be provided with the necessary financial resources to proceed with the case legally and to facilitate the healing necessary.
• Immediate implementation of the CBCI Guidelines, 2017 in the Church in India, and the civil laws applicable to grievance redressal mechanisms in cases of sexual abuse.

We urgently request you, Pope Francis, to engage and guide the Indian Church to address this situation in a manner that restores our faith in the Church as an institution that stands for justice and due process.
We the undersigned place our trust in your wisdom and await your intervention,

Cc  to:

1. Most Rev. Giambattista Diquattro, The Apostolic Nuncio to India
2. His Eminence Oswald Cardinal Gracias, President CBCI
3. Most Rev. Theodore Mascarenhas SFX, Secretary General CBCI IWTF India
4. Most Rev. Agnelo Gracias, Apostolic Administrator, Jalandhar Diocese
5. His Eminence Cardinal George Alencherry, Major Archbishop of the Syro – Malabar Catholic Church

6. Most Rev. Jacob Manathodath, Apostolic Administrator of the Diocese of ErnakulamAngamaly
7. Archbishop Maria Calist Soosa Pakiam, President KCBC 8. Bishops in India
9. Catholic Bishops Conference of India, CBCI, Council for Women

10.Conference of Religious India, CRI, Executive Members
11.International Union of Superiors General, UISG
12.Congregation for the Institutes of Consecrated Life
13. Pontifical Commission for Protection of Minors


You may also like...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.