Karan Thapar , in Hindusstan Times, Jan 28, 2017
During the campaign US President Donald Trump famously said “I am a big fan of Hindu. I am a big fan of India.” Did he mean it or was it just campaign rhetoric? (REUTERS)
(Note: Regarding Trump’s foreign relations two traits seem rather clear: his warm relation to Russia because of camaraderie with Putin; his bitter dislike to Muslims and due to which his antipathy bordering on hostility to all countries whence Muslims flock to US.
Just another thing to be noted is what we often said “office makes the man”, one has to be “slow in judging” as Pope also warned us. Take the example of meeting his meeting with UK’s Teresa May. He has not made her “Blaire Poodle” as feared. Their meeting turned out to be much better than expected.
But when two people repeat the same slogan: “Buy American, hire Amerian against Make in India, Buy Indian” who is going to give in” Modi or Trump? Or will they actually repeat that when they actually meet? As for outsourcing and insourcing, ‘Brain drain’ and ‘Brain gain’ we know the clear position of Trump. But he could make adjustments as he did with Theresa May for the sake of mutual benefit.
But already a far Right winger Steve Bannon, Trump’s chief strategist, has has in advance complained about the number of Indians working in Silicon Valley and urged Trump to slash H-1B visas. Whom will he listen? To counter balance here we have two American Indian governors, more members in the house and the reported love of Trump for Hindus etc. So trump’s response to Modi is going to depend on many factors. So we still have to wait and see. jmes kottoor, editor)
Does Donald Trump present an opportunity or a challenge for India? That depends on how seriously you take what he’s said. Until he acts we’ve nothing else to go by.
First, the impact of his broad handling of international relations. Trump has spoken warmly of President Putin, talked of lifting sanctions and wants engagement with Moscow. His secretary of state is a close friend of the Russian President. In contrast, Trump has threatened a tougher line against China. The one-China policy is open for reconsideration and the country could be penalised for currency manipulation.
Friendly relations between the United States and Russia suit India because we can then pursue closer relations with both without contradiction. Also, a US-Russia détente would diminish Russia’s dependence on Beijing. And any policy that confronts China’s expansion can’t disadvantage India.
More important is Trump’s direct impact. During the campaign he famously said “I am a big fan of Hindu. I am a big fan of India.” Did he mean it or was it just campaign rhetoric? In terms of Indo-Pakistan relations, Nawaz Sharif claims Trump’s expressed a willingness to sort out Indo-Pak differences. Vice President Mike Pence is also reported to have concurred in an NBC interview. However, most people think that’s unlikely.
During the campaign Trump called Pakistan “the most dangerous country in the world today” and said “the only country that can check Pakistan is India”. Though he hasn’t repeated this after the election his key appointments think similarly. At his confirmation, Defence Secretary Gen. Mattis spoke of “Pakistan’s need to expel or neutralise externally-focused militant groups that operate within its border.” The National Security Advisor, Gen. Flynn, in his book, the Field of Fight, writes: “Countries like Pakistan need to be told we will not tolerate terrorist training camps and safe havens … they are going to have to choose and if they continue to help the jihadis we are going to treat them harshly.” That suggests a tougher stand which can only be good news for India.
On other issues, like membership of the Nuclear Suppliers Group or a permanent seat on the Security Council, we don’t have clarity. It’s unlikely Trump will reverse Obama’s commitments but he may not accord them the same priority.
Now to the economic impact. The key concern is what happens to H1B visas. Both the US president and his attorney general talk of reducing H1B visas. This would be bad news for India’s information technology industry, 60% of whose $108 billion exports go to the US. Companies like Infosys, Wipro and TCS could suffer.
However, that could also impact the American enterprises which rely on them. As the latter’s costs rise they’ll be passed on to their American customers. The question is could this make Trump change his position? No one really knows.
Finally, what about Trump’s attitude to American companies that establish factories abroad? Ford has three in India and intends to export most of its cars. Now, undoubtedly, exports to the US will be affected but will that make such companies rethink their India strategy? I guess that depends on how badly they’re affected.
If all this suggests we have more questions than answers that’s undeniable. But a Trump-like change creates worrying doubts alongside great expectations and you have to keep your fingers crossed till you discover what will actually happen.