By C. Raja Mohan, in the Indian Express, January 20, 2017
To deal with an unpredictable US, India will need to be more skilful, less a prisoner of the past
(Note: “India never had such a disgustingly attention seeking PM”, some one had tweeted recently. May be, may not be, but there is one in US to beat him, in Trump who has already immortalised himself in a wax figure at Madame Tussauds, before he was crowned President.
Apart from such superficial things, this article by Raja Mohanin the Indian Express is replete practical suggestions for the Modi Govenment and the external affairs ministers to take serious note of. It is all summed in his one sentence: “it will not be business as usual in America for the next four years.” Modiji made fantastic progress in bringing US and India close to each other through his many visits to US and especially his camaraderie with the former President Obama, to the envy of other world leaders and politicians at home. It is a million $ question if he can ever succeed to do a repeat of such a feat with President Donald. We wish he succeeds. What counts most between two nations are personal relationships of the heads of states and secondly between peoples of the two countries.
For one thing Trump is already well disposed to Indians in US. He already described them as brainy and hard working. His only complaint was Indians studying there should not go back to India but stay on to work in US so that they become a brain-gain not a brain-drain for US. This is what is implied when the writer speaks of “Insourcing and outsourcing”. Once brainy Indians stay on US won’t be facing the need to out source to Bangalore. A contingent of six Indian Diaspora in American congress is proof of brain-gain from India.
These could be some of the points Modi could work on when he would be meeting the new US president. The author of the article Raja Mohon deserves special thanks for highlighting so many vexing issues between US and India for the study and consideration of our present political leadership in India. james kottoor, editor).
As Donald Trump is sworn in as the 45th president of the United States, India must prepare for the extraordinary turbulence in America’s internal and external orientation. Although the new president is well disposed towards India, his efforts to change America’s trajectory will have huge economic and political consequences for India.
Delhi must be nimble enough to cope with the challenges and take advantage of the new possibilities generated by Trump over the next four years. Nearly two decades of steady improvement in bilateral relations across different administrations in Washington and Delhi has indeed made the relationship less vulnerable to wild oscillations.
In Washington, Delhi has accumulated an abundance of bipartisan goodwill. In Delhi, building on the efforts of his three recent predecessors — P.V. Narasimha Rao, Atal Bihari Vajpayee and Manmohan Singh — Prime Minister Narendra Modihas made bold to declare that India has overcome its past hesitations in engaging America.
On its part, Washington has learnt to curb the recurring itch to mediate in the Kashmir dispute between India and Pakistan. The nuclear dispute that once roiled relations is now behind us. There is a solid business relationship — with annual trade at more than a 100 billion dollars — and a deepening cooperation on bilateral, regional and global issues.
The Indian diaspora has steadily grown in its influence in American domestic politics — it has sent five men and women to the House of Representatives in the 2016 elections. California has also elected Kamala Harris to become the first ever Indian-American senator. This contingent of six from the Indian diaspora is the largest ever to be elected to the US Congress.Under Modi, India has celebrated the achievements of the diaspora in America and values its role as a bridge between the two nations.
This good news for India is complicated by the fact that the United States has entered an unpredictable phase under Trump. Many propositions that India has taken for granted about the United States — open borders, leadership of the liberal global economic order and military dominance over the Eurasian landmass since the middle of the 20th century — are being challenged by Trump.
Trump has won by promising to curb immigration into the United States by building a wall on the border with Mexico and throwing out those staying on illegally. He has threatened to impose “extreme vetting” on visitors from the Muslim world. He argues that American workers are victims of economic globalisation.
He believes the US taxpayers pay too high a price for American military alliances abroad. He has dismissed the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation, the powerful seven-decade-old Euro-Atlantic alliance, as “obsolete”. Trump demands that US allies in Asia, Japan and South Korea take a larger share of the defence burden.
Trump’s refusal to moderate either the tone or substance of his controversial positions since the election suggests that it will not be business as usual in America for the next four years. To be sure, Trump’s policies will be severely contested in Washington in the US Congress by the opposition Democrats as well as leading lights of his own Republican Party. The mainstream policy and media establishments are already at war with Trump. Even limited successes for Trump, however, would mean that Delhi will be dealing with a very different United States than it has known since Independence.
For one, Delhi will have to quickly come to terms with the historic shift in America’s approach to economic globalisation under Trump. For nearly three decades, Delhi has defined its approach to globalisation in terms of resisting American pressures for liberalisation and standing up to the US in multilateral economic forums. It has repeatedly cried wolf about America’s protectionism. Delhi might now have the opportunity to see what even a moderately protectionist America might really look like.
Insourcing of skilled Indian labour through the H1B visa system and outsourcing of work to Bengaluru are bound to get harder under Trump. Delhi’s somewhat perverse cheer at Trump slaying the Trans Pacific Partnership might be shortlived as many trade partners of the United States embark, kicking and screaming, upon negotiating bilateral deals with Washington.
Delhi needs to end its defensive crouch on external economic engagement and re-position itself to cope with the structural changes that Trump threatens to engineer in the global economic order. As in the economic, so in the political domain, Delhi will have to stop being defensive.
Even as Delhi sought a strategic partnership with America over the last two decades, it invested in insuring against American power in the unipolar world by working with Russia and China for a “multipolar” world. That strategy, arguably, has only helped lend legitimacy to China’s new global role and Russian bargaining power with the West, while slowing down the pace of constructing India’s partnership with the US.
As Moscow pursues a reset with Trump’s Washington, China will seek to postpone, if not limit the potential confrontation with America. Like Moscow and Beijing, Delhi must focus more on securing the national interest in a fluid moment in great power relations.
It can’t afford to remain a prisoner of slogans like multi-polarity. Russia and China will abandon that slogan the minute they have sustainable deals with Trump. The Indian strategic community often complains about America’s “transactional” approach. Delhi must expect Trump, who published the book The Art of the Deal in 1987, to be the epitome of this approach.
While he threatens a trade war and dumps the “One China” policy, Trump has signaled the intent to renegotiate the terms of endearment with Beijing. To succeed in Trump’s world, Prime Minister Modi will need all his skills at identifying India’s potential deals with America and closing the transactions after intensive bargaining.