Hindutva mobs flex Muscles against Muslims Sikhs, Christians should speak up before it’s too late
Sunny Hundal in Hindustan Times, Apr 29, 2017
India’s religious minorities have always been suspicious of Hindutva, aware that one day they could be on the receiving end of its intolerance. That day is arriving faster than they realise.
Cover Photo: Sikhs in attendance during a vigil in honour of Srinivas Kuchibhotla, who was shot and killed in the USA. (REUTERS)
(Note: Whatever affects our neighbour badly, no matter who he/she is and what he/she is (Hindu, Muslim, Christian, rich or poor) will eventually affect us. Therefore we should be equally concerned and should not wait to act till it happens to us. This is the lesson Sunny Hundal the London based writer conveys to us. To clinch this lesson his quote is worth repeating:
“First they came for the Socialists, and I did not speak out – because I was not a Socialist.” Then they came for the Trade Unionists and the same happened. Then the Jews. “Then they came for me — and there was no one left to speak for me.” A German priest was expressing his regret for not opposing Hitler after the first world war.
Today war cries are heard from Trump in US and North Korean president. And the only Christian who is ever awake to constantly warn a selfish humanity unconcerned about the miserable victims of war and terror, seems to be Pope Francis. There is an on-going war waging in India between Hindutva groups and other minorities. Hinduism is not a war-mongering religion, but a pacific one, as demonstrated by Ashoka who became Budhist saying: “War no more.”
Hindutva is the aggressive version manufactured by RSS and Sangh Parivar now getting more bold under a BJP rule especially against Muslims and less frequently against Christians. Christians in India, unlike Pope Francis seldom raise their voice unless and until they are directly targeted. This attitude is most pronounced among Catholics. This must change in their own interest, following the example of Francis. “Peace to men of good will!” The first duty of Christians is to be builders of bridges, not walls like Trump, and builders of peace; to be in the forefront whenever and wherever their neighbour is attacked, no matter which community he/she belongs. james kottoor, editor).
As right wing forces flex their Hindutva muscles and use them against Muslims across the country, Sikhs and Christians will be watching in worry. But the time for them to speak out is now, not when the mob comes for them. By then it will be too late.
Sikhs know this better than any other religious minority in India. The state-directed genocide in 1984 showed that Indian politicians rarely face charges for stirring up hatred against non-Hindus. But what is at stake here for Sikhs isn’t just their own safety but the protection of an important principle.
If you are born into a Sikh family, like myself, chances are you have been taught about the sacrifice of Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji. In 1675 a group of fearful Hindu pundits approached the Guru to ask for his help against the Mughal king Aurangzeb, who wanted to forcibly convert them to Islam. The Guru had a challenge for the king. If he could convert him to Islam then the Kashmiri pandits would follow. But, of course, Aurangzeb was unsuccessful and Guru Tegh Bahadur paid for his principles with his life.
The ninth Guru of the Sikhs wasn’t taking the side of Hindus against Muslims, he died to defend the right to practice religion without intimidation. But his sacrifice was more than just a lesson for Sikhs, it was also an example. Guru Tegh Bahadur wanted Sikhs to protect others from such intimidation too.
This is why the growing number of incidents of violent cow-vigilantism should matter to Sikhs, Christians and other minorities. While many Hindus pretend that Muslims are being targeted only for violating the law and ignoring their sentiments, it is clear this is a lie. In numerous cases, Muslims have been murdered merely on a vague suspicion of eating beef or transporting cows, without evidence. Hindus caught committing the same crime have been let go.
Cows should be protected through democratic means, not mob justice. This is no better than Pakistanis murdering Hindus on suspicion of ‘blasphemy’. In headlines around the world, Indian politicians are seen as caring more for the safety of cows than women. Of course Hindus have the right to worship the cow and protect it from harm if they believe it is holy. And as a vegetarian, I also believe eating meat is wrong (as do many Sikhs). So in principle I actually agree with the gau-rakshaks.
But this is no more than a campaign of hate and intimidation against a religious group. This is Hindutva’s way of striking at Pakistan. The cow vigilantes hate Aurangzeb and all he stood for, but they have become him.
Sikhs, Christians and others should see it as a warning. The Hindutva movement needs to keep creating controversies to polarise the nation. Like a parasite it will grow by consuming its victim and then moving to the next one.
A famous European quote comes to mind. After the Second World War a German priest spoke of his regret in not opposing Hitler earlier. He wrote: “First they came for the Socialists, and I did not speak out – because I was not a Socialist.” Then they came for the Trade Unionists and the same happened. Then the Jews. “Then they came for me — and there was no one left to speak for me.”
India’s religious minorities have always been suspicious of Hindutva, aware that one day they could be on the receiving end of its intolerance. That day is arriving faster than they realise.
Sunny Hundal is a writer and lecturer on digital journalism based in London.The views expressed are personal.
